BankSouth Fraudcast: Fraud in Lending

Inside the Fraudcast

The BankSouth Fraudcast returns with another conversation focused on protecting our customers, communities, and employees from evolving financial threats. In this episode, Bryce McCuin, Director of Marketing at BankSouth, is joined by Dawn Taylor, Chief Credit Officer, who offers her insight on one of the most complex areas of financial crime — lending fraud. Together, they explore how this type of fraud occurs, its impact on borrowers and banks alike, and the steps BankSouth takes to detect and prevent it.

The Role of the Chief Credit Officer

As Chief Credit Officer, Dawn Taylor oversees the health and integrity of BankSouth’s loan portfolio — which makes up roughly 90–93% of the bank’s assets. Her role ensures that loans are well-graded, properly monitored, and compliant with regulatory and risk standards. Working closely with a team of experienced professionals, she helps guide responsible, sustainable lending decisions that balance opportunity with security.

What Is Lending Fraud?

Lending fraud occurs when someone intentionally provides false or misleading information to a bank in order to obtain a loan. This can involve falsified income, fabricated employment details, or misrepresented loan purposes — such as claiming personal occupancy on a property intended for rental or resale. These are not minor errors; they are deliberate, illegal acts that can lead to serious penalties and prosecution.

Common Forms of Lending Fraud

Application Fraud

Applicants falsify documentation or personal details to qualify for loans they wouldn’t otherwise receive. In one case, a borrower claiming to be a childcare worker reported an annual income of $125,000. After submitting a fake pay stub, their nervous behavior and inconsistent answers raised red flags — ultimately uncovering the fraud.

Occupancy Fraud

This occurs when borrowers misstate their intent to live in a property to receive better loan terms. For example, claiming a home will be their primary residence when it’s actually intended for rental or resale.

Elder Exploitation in Lending

Fraudsters sometimes target elderly individuals — or pressure them through relatives — to co-sign or guarantee loans. In these cases, the elder may unknowingly risk their savings or certificates of deposit. BankSouth’s employees are trained to protect these customers by:

• Speaking privately with the individual.
• Confirming their understanding and intent.
• Declining the loan if there’s any indication of discomfort or coercion.

Recognizing Red Flags

• Income or job information that doesn’t seem realistic for the position or industry.
• Inconsistent stories or evasive answers from the borrower.
• Nervous behavior during questioning.
• Unverifiable documents, such as fake pay stubs or tax returns.
• And above all — trust your gut. If something feels off, it likely is.

“If it’s too good to be true, it probably isn’t true.” — Dawn Taylor

The Ripple Effect of Lending Fraud

Lending fraud doesn’t just harm the bank — it affects everyone involved.

For the Fraudster: It’s a criminal offense with severe legal penalties.

For Victims: It can result in financial loss, damaged credit, or stolen identities.

For Banks: It leads to financial losses that can reach into the millions, as well as reputational harm when cases go public. In one instance, a small community bank faced major fallout after a multimillion-dollar fraudulent loan appeared on the front page of local news — an incident that took years to rebuild trust from.

Real-Life Case Examples

Case 1: The $5 Million Loan

A borrower applied for a $5 million home loan in Florida with seemingly flawless credentials. However, an underwriter’s background check revealed multiple lawsuits and prior fraud claims against the applicant, including past incidents of collecting earnest money and disappearing. The loan was declined — preventing a multimillion-dollar loss.

Case 2: The Insider Fraud

A loan officer fluent in another language built a client base within a specific community. Due to language barriers, they operated independently and avoided oversight — creating and cycling fake loans over several years. The scheme ultimately caused millions in losses and lasting reputational damage. The lesson, as Dawn emphasizes: don’t be an island. Collaboration is key to prevention.

Prevention: How to Stop Lending Fraud Before It Happens

Know Your Customer (KYC)

• Meet borrowers face-to-face whenever possible.
• Verify identity with multiple forms of ID.
• Build familiarity and trust — know who you’re lending to.

Trust Your Instincts

• If something feels suspicious, speak up — even if it turns out to be nothing.
• Instinct is often the first line of defense against fraud.

Verify Information Independently

• Use public record searches and online tools to confirm details.
• Check for lawsuits, liens, or prior fraud claims.

Collaborate Internally

• Don’t work in isolation. Share concerns early with managers and teammates.
• The sooner suspicions are raised, the easier it is to prevent losses.

Dawn Taylor’s Three Core Takeaways

1. Know Your Customer — Build relationships and verify their story.
2. Trust Your Gut — Instinct is your best fraud detector.
3. Don’t Be an Island — Communication and teamwork prevent oversight.

Closing Message

Lending fraud affects everyone — from borrowers to communities to banks. Prevention starts with awareness, diligence, and teamwork. As Dawn Taylor reminds us:

“We want loans that can be paid back — not fraudulent loans.”

For more on how to protect yourself and your finances, visit our Fraud Prevention page or explore other episodes of the BankSouth Fraudcast.

Stay Informed with Fraud Watch

Join the BankSouth Fraud Watch monthly newsletter to stay informed about the latest scams, prevention tips, and fraud awareness updates. Fill out the form below to subscribe and help keep yourself and your community protected.